D.C. v. Harvard-Westlake School, No. B204634 - California Case Law
California Case Law - The FindLaw California Supreme Court and Courts of Appeal Opinion Summaries Blog

D.C. v. Harvard-Westlake School, No. B204634

In an action against plaintiff's school claiming it was liable under hate crimes laws for death threats he received from classmates who misperceived his sexual orientation, judgment granting petition to confirm an arbitration award against plaintiff and denying a petition to vacate is reversed where: 1) plaintiff and his parents filed suit against a school, seeking remedies under the California hate crimes laws, and since hate crimes laws constitute unwaivable statutory rights comparable to antidiscrimination laws, neither the student nor his parents may be required to pay any type of arbitral expense that would not be imposed were the dispute adjudicated in court; and 2) hate crimes laws prohibit an award of fees to a prevailing defendant, and thus render the award of attorney's fees in the case invalid. On remand, the trial court must ensure that the arbitration award does not include any inappropriate arbitral expenses or any attorney's fees prohibited by hate crimes laws.

Read D.C. v. Harvard-Westlake School, No. B204634

Appellate Information

Filed August 14, 2009

Judges

Opinion by Judge Mallano

Dissent by Judge Rothschild

Counsel

For Appellants:

Robert S. Gerstein, Los Angeles, CA

For Respondents:

Stuart W. Rudnick, Musick, Peeler & Garrett, Los Angeles, CA

Kent A. Halkett, Musick, Peeler & Garrett, Los Angeles, CA