California Case Law - The FindLaw California Supreme Court and Courts of Appeal Opinion Summaries Blog

People v. Superior Ct., No. S164614

In a prosecution of defendant for felony murders, judgment of a court of appeal setting aside a superior court's ruling prohibiting the prosecution at issue based on the doctrine of nonmutual collateral estoppel is affirmed where: 1) a verdict regarding one defendant has no effect on the trial of a different defendant, and courts should determine the propriety of a prosecution based on that prosecutions' own record, not a different record; and 2) nonmutual estoppel does not apply to verdicts in criminal cases. 

Read People v. Superior Ct., No. S164614 [HTML]

Read People v. Superior Ct., No. S164614 [PDF]

Appellate Information
Appeal from Yuba County, No. CFR0600126

Filed February 8, 2010

Before:  George, C. J., Baxter, J., Corrigan, J.,  Kennard, J.,  Moreno, J., and Werdegar, J.

Opinion by Chin, J.

For Appellant:  Edmund G. Brown, Jr., Attorney General, Dane R. Gillette, Chief Assistant Attorney General, Michael Farrell, Assistant Attorney General, John G. McLean, R. Todd Marshall, George M. Hendrick, Deputy Attorneys General

For Appellee:  N/A