Sigmund v. Starwood Urban Retail VI, LLC, No. 08-7137 - DC Circuit
DC Circuit - The FindLaw DC Circuit Court of Appeals Opinion Summaries Blog

Sigmund v. Starwood Urban Retail VI, LLC, No. 08-7137

Sigmund v. Starwood Urban Retail VI, LLC, No. 08-7137, involved an action against the owners of a parking garage where plaintiff was injured by a car bombing.  The court affirmed summary judgment for defendants, on the ground that the accidental victim of a car bomb that plaintiff's half-brother intended for their father could not recover from the third-party defendants he sued unless his half-brother's crime was foreseeable.

As the court wrote:  "Solon, the ancient Athenian lawgiver, made no law against patricide because he thought it impossible that anyone could commit so unnatural a crime. Two and a half millennia later, Freud famously claimed the opposite -- that every son harbors murderous impulses toward his father. In this case, we side with the lawyer not the psychoanalyst. Donald Sigmund, the accidental victim of a car bomb that his half-brother intended for their father, cannot recover from the third-party defendants he has sued unless his half-brother's crime was foreseeable. We conclude that neither that crime nor any similar one was foreseeable, and thus affirm the district court's grant of summary judgment in favor of the defendants."

Related Resources