Federal Circuit - The FindLaw Federal Circuit Court of Appeals Opinion Summaries Blog

December 2014 Archives

Year in Review 2014: The 10 Most Popular Federal Cir. Blog Posts

This circuit. This glorious Federal Circuit, with its unique, specialized jurisdiction over a few niche areas of law. Typically, this circuit's run-of-the-mill patent decisions are a bit dry.

But 2014 was different. This past year brought a whole lot of Supreme Court intervention, a scandal that led to a resignation and reprimand, and a new chief judge. In other words: juicy blog material.

Here's what you found most interesting, judging by traffic numbers:

Fed. Cir. Upholds Internet Business Method Patent

Over here at FindLaw's Federal Circuit blog, we're no fans of business method patents. Every chance we get, we write about, and celebrate, another Federal Circuit opinion using Alice v. CLS Bank to invalidate phony baloney "on a computer" method patents.

After a string of Alice success stories, in which the Federal Circuit struck patents for regular old, ordinary, analog things done on a computer, the court has upheld a business method patent because the problem the patent sought to solve actually was something unique to the Internet.

A Little Info About the Final Product Doesn't Break EMVR: Fed Cir.

The "entire market value rule" (EMVR) is a way of limiting damages on patent infringement. It requires the prevailing party in a patent infringement case to base its damages only on the value of the infringing component in a device, not the value of the entire device itself.

Ericsson sued big-name makers of network technology like D-Link and Netgear, and computer manufacturers like Toshiba and Dell, claiming they made devices with 802.11n-compliant wireless chips and therefore needed a license.

Ericsson won at trial, but the real question on appeal is whether its damage award broke the EMVR.