U.S. First Circuit - The FindLaw 1st Circuit Court of Appeals News and Information Blog

Ramirez-Lebron v. Int'l Shipping Agency, Inc. , No.08-2321

In a labor dispute involving seniority rights between two employee groups of defendant's, district court's dismissal of the complaint is reversed and remanded as, the district court erroneously dismissed plaintiffs' complaint, as the factual allegations are sufficient under section 301 to establish plaintiffs' standing and sustain their claim that defendant, by entering into a side agreement with the other employees designed to procure an arbitration award, breached the CBA and effectively repudiated its arbitration provision, thereby estopping defendant from posing the defense of exhaustion.   

Read Ramirez-Lebron v. Int'l Shipping Agency, Inc. , No.08-2321

Appellate Information

Appeal from the United States District Court for the District of Puerto Rico

Decided January 29, 2010


Before:  Torruella, Baldock, and Lipez, Circuit Judges

Opinion by  Circuit Judge Baldock


For Appellant:  Juan H. Saavedra Castro

For Appellee:       Antonio Cuevas Delgado