Estrada v. State of Rhode Island, No. 09-1149 - Criminal Law - U.S. First Circuit
U.S. First Circuit - The FindLaw 1st Circuit Court of Appeals News and Information Blog

Estrada v. State of Rhode Island, No. 09-1149

In plaintiffs' action challenging the constitutionality of the actions of a police officer during a traffic stop, summary judgment in favor of defendant is affirmed where: 1) the officer is entitled to federal and state qualified immunity for any possible constitutional violations that he may have committed in asking the van's passengers questions about their immigration status and in contacting ICE; 2) the officer is entitled to qualified immunity for alleged violations of state or federal laws surrounding the seizure of plaintiffs and their subsequent escort to ICE office; 3) officer is entitled to qualified immunity for both pat down searches under federal and state law; and 4) the officer is entitled to qualified immunity for all of the challenged actions with respect to the Rhode Island Racial Profiling Prevention Act. 

Read Estrada v. State of Rhode Island, No. 09-1149

Appellate Information

Appeal from the United States District Court for the District of Rhode Island

Decided February 4, 2010

Judges

Before:  Lynch, Chief Judge, Torruella and Howard, Circuit Judges

Opinion by  Circuit Judge Torruella

Counsel

For Appellant:    V. Edward Formisano, American Civil Liberties Union, Rhode Island Affiliate, Sinapi, Formisano, & Co., Ltd.,

For Appellee:    John M. Moreira, Special Assistant Attorney General, Patrick C. Lynch, Attorney General, James R. Lee and Brenda D. Baum, Assistants Attorney General