Dillion v. Select Potfolio Servicing, 09-1469 - U.S. First Circuit
U.S. First Circuit - The FindLaw 1st Circuit Court of Appeals News and Information Blog

Dillion v. Select Potfolio Servicing, 09-1469

Dismissal of an action for damages for engaging in illegal practices in foreclosure based on res judicata

Dillion v. Select Potfolio Servicing, 09-1469, concerned a challenge to the district court's grant of summary judgment in favor of the defendants in plaintiff's new suit against the defendants seeking damages claims under new theories, in determining that plaintiff's claims are foreclosed by res judicata, following an injunction against defendants for engaging in illegal practices in seeking to foreclose upon plaintiff's home mortgage.


In affirming the judgment, the court held that plaintiff has waived his argument that he could not have brought his present claims in the first action because he was then subject to the preliminary settlement in the class action against defendants.  The court held that plaintiff's argument that his present claims arose after he filed the first action and thus constitute a separate cause of action is meritless as he has not raised a material fact in this action that he did not allege in the prior action.  Lastly, the plaintiff has waived his argument that he could not have raised his avoidance of note claim during his first action because the defendants had falsely represented during that action that they owned the note.

Related Link: