The Solicitor - The FindLaw UK Life, Family and Workplace Law Blog

Constructive Dismissal

Constructive Dismissal - Constructive Dismissal Solicitor

Where you feel forced to resign because of your employer's unlawful behaviour, you may be able to claim for constructive dismissal.

Constructive dismissal cases are hard to win, so you should always seek advice before leaving your job. Factors such as your employment status, the terms of your employment contract, length of service, and reasons for leaving all require consideration.

If you need legal advice on constructive dismissal, regardless of where you’re located – be it in London, Manchester, Birmingham, Bristol, Leeds, Sheffield, Glasgow, Edinburgh, Cardiff, Belfast, or elsewhere – you should speak to a local solicitor who specializes in employment law.


Recently in Constructive Dismissal Category

Constructive Dismissal: Strike 1 to "Decorative Dumb Blonde"

| No TrackBacks

There was another twist in Jordan Wimmer's £4 million constructive dismissal case against Nomos Capital founder Mark Lowe this week, as the defendant took the stand.  Lowe admitted to sending sexually explicit emails to female employees and calling Wimmer a "dumb blonde" and "decorative"; he also said he had a "marked preference" for female sales staff, which he justified as "pure commercial sense."  Wimmer also produced one email in which Lowe asked her whether an internship candidate was "cute" or "blonde."

But Lowe rejected Wimmer's claims that he'd hired escorts, who accompanied him to business meetings, and a hitman to kill her.  He also denied accusations that he made sexual advances towards Wimmer, saying he always treated her "in a gentlemanly way."

Constructive Dismissal: Exec Says Boss Hired Hitman To Kill Her

| No TrackBacks

Former Nomus Capital executive Jordan Wimmer, who is suing ex-boss Mark Lowe for , , , and , has claimed he hired a Russian hitman to kill her.

Ms. Wimmer has already claimed she was .

Constructive Dismissal: City Exec Claims Boss Branded Her A Bimbo

| No TrackBacks

Jordan Wimmer, 29, of Chelsea, west London, says her boss Mark Lowe, founder and owner of Nomos Capital, branded her a "bimbo" and "stupid blonde," and forced her to quit her £500,000-a-year job as a marketing executive.  The Canadian is now suing Lowe for £4 million, claiming , , , and .

Wimmer claims was forced to watch father-of-two Lowe have a lap dance at a burlesque club in Paris "under great duress."  She also alleges he invited a young Thai escort to business meetings: "In spite of everyone else wearing formal business attire, [the escort] wore hot pants which barely covered her buttocks, stilettos, and no stockings."

Laws In The Workplace

| No TrackBacks

Over the past , we've taken a look at a number of different

We began with , , and .

After that, we looked at and - including the .

Next, we discussed (including the ); ; ; and discrimination on grounds of , , and .

We then considered ; ; the ; and .  We also discussed .

After this, we looked at the significance of and .

From here, we analysed , , and .

We next looked at and .

Constructive Dismissal: Curbishley Wins Case Against West Ham

| No TrackBacks

Alan Curbishley has won his case for  against West Ham United.  Curbishley left Upton Park in September 2008 after less than two years in charge - in circumstances very similar to - claiming he was forced to resign because the club ignored a clause in his contract giving him the final word on player transfers.

A Premier League arbitration tribunal unanimously upheld Curbishley's claim and dismissed a counter-claim by West Ham for the cost of employing Gianfranco Zola, his successor, and Steve Clarke, his assistant.  The tribunal will now assess how much compensation the club will have to pay Curbishley for .

"I am obviously delighted with this result," Curbishley said.  "I very much enjoyed my time at West Ham and never wanted to leave, but when I joined them I insisted that my contract contain a clause confirming that I would have final say on the selection of players to be transferred to and from the club.

Blowing The Whistle At Work? Are You Protected? - Part 4

| No TrackBacks

Dismissal or victimisation for blowing the whistle

If someone is dismissed or victimised after blowing the whistle, the level of protection they receive depends on whether they qualify as an .

Employees

If an employee is dismissed for whistleblowing, they can claim   - even if they don't have one year's service 

  • Normally, under the , only employees who have a year's continuity of service at the date of dismissal, or who have been dismissed without notice and are within a week of gaining a year's continuity of service, can make a claim.

  • Note also that in this context the word dismissal includes .

If an employee is victimised or treated worse after blowing the whistle they can also bring a claim for 'detrimental treatment' (see below).

Constructive Dismissal: 'Black Box' Hearing Ends

| No TrackBacks

Ruth Matthews, 60, former head of support services at Inverness Leisure complex, has brought a claim for  against her former employer, alleging she was forced to quit after two years of being "victimised" and "manipulated."

It would seem her relationship with the general manager at the complex, James Martin, lies at the heart of the dispute.  This first became strained in 2007 after he blamed her for an administrative error.

Mr. Martin alleges the incident prompted Ms. Matthews to compile a "" against him.  During the hearing, she made a series of allegations, including overstaffing, bullying, cronyism, and favouritism; she also claimed one employee took 27 cigarette breaks in a single shift, which seriously endangered health & safety.

Whistleblowing & Constructive Dismissal

| No TrackBacks

Whistleblowing has received a lot of media attention in recent weeks: we had the injunction on the reporting of Paul Farrelly's question in Parliament, which caused a ; and before that, we had news of Terry Pearson, a Scottish operations supervisor, who blew the whistle on the working at the US Embassy in Afghanistan.

Mr. Pearson witnessed drunken parties involving guards urinating and performing sex acts on each order in order to win promotion or assignment to preferable shifts.  After telling his boss, however, he claims he was forced out of his job.

Mr. Pearson told the :

"Both as a military officer and a contractor, I have never seen anything as disgusting and ultimately harmful to morale and security as what I saw in Kabul.  But as soon as I said anything, it was definitely a case of 'get rid of the whistleblower'."

Mr. Pearson has struggled to find a new job since he left Afghanistan:

"It's hard because I need a job.  But I don't regret what I did.  I believe I did the right thing."

Indeed, three weeks ago, he was flown to Washington D.C. to give evidence before a US government committee investigating the scandal, which was widely covered by TV networks around the world.

And he now plans to sue his former employer for .

How To Prove Constructive Dismissal

| No TrackBacks
A recruitment consultant who alleged her manger bullied her into attending a strip club with clients has failed to prove before an employment tribunal in South London.

Rachel Kelly, 38, of Isleworth, Middlesex, sued former employer IDPP Consulting and her line manager, Danny Whelan, for , , and , and claimed £175,000 compensation.

Ms. Kelly claimed she shared a private lap-dance with Mr. Whelan "under great duress."  The tribunal was unsympathetic, however, and ruled there was no management bullying and Ms. Kelly was a "willing participant."  "She was not compelled to go to the club and could have refused to attend," it said.

Witnesses described how Ms. Kelly tried to perform a drunken pole dance at the club.  They also alleged she laughed throughout the lap-dance with Mr. Whelan and "held court" at work the next day to describe her drunken antics.

One witness recalled how she "proclaimed to anyone who would listen all of the details and she had thought it very amusing."

In announcing its verdict, the tribunal said:

Constructive Dismissal: Keegan Wins £2 Million Compensation

| No TrackBacks

The arbitration panel convened to settle the has awarded Keegan £2 million compensation.

It ruled Keegan was from his post as Newcastle manager after the club signed Uruguayan midfielder Ignacio Gonzalez against his wishes and in breach of his employment contract.

The reports the award could have been higher but for a clause in Keegan's contract imposing a £2 million compensation ceiling on any pay-off in the event of his dismissal or resignation.

Responding to the panel's verdict, Keegan said:

Constructive Dismissal In The News

| No TrackBacks

Constructive dismissal has received a lot of press attention lately.  The has seen claims soar and of course there was also ...

"Hold on," I hear you say, "Keegan wasn't sacked, he resigned." Well, you're right.  But resignation is a prerequisite for constructive dismissal.

In a nutshell, you may have a claim for  if you're forced to resign because of your employer's unlawful behaviour.

To prove constructive dismissal, you must be able to demonstrate that your former employer committed a serious breach of contract, you did not accept the breach, and you felt forced to resign because of that breach.

Examples of serious breaches of contract in this context include the following:

Unfair Dismissal: Prison Guard Branded 'Too Sexy' Wins Case

| No TrackBacks

A prison officer who claimed her co-workers hounded her out of her job by repeatedly criticising her for being "too sexy" and "glammed up," has won her case against Her Majesty's Prison Service for , , and .

In July, , told an how colleagues at Brinsford Young Offenders' Institution complained that she wore too much make-up and that her clothing was too provocative.

A former colleague, Michael Doolan, told the tribunal her appearance was "overbearing" and brought  "unwarranted attention" from inmates.  Mr. Doolan said Ms. Kajla wore a significant amount of make-up including "heavy eyeliner, dark mascara, rouge on her cheeks and embossed lipstick."

Ms. Kajila claimed she was often mocked and reprimanded in front of inmates and other staff, which made her feel harassed and humiliated.  She told the tribunal: "I couldn't sleep at night because of the bullying and harassment.  I lost weight and decided I couldn't take it any longer and resigned."

Kevin Keegan vs. Newcastle United Hearing Begins

| No TrackBacks

An arbitration hearing to settle the has begun.  Keegan reportedly wants £8 million in compensation for being  from his post as Newcastle manager due to a lack of autonomy over transfers.

The reports a panel consisting of two lawyers and one senior sports administrator will hear evidence from Dennis Wise, Newcastle's former director of football, and also listen to a counter-claim from Mike Ashley, the club's owner, that Keegan is culpable for breach of contract.

Kevin Keegan's Case For Constructive Dismissal

| No TrackBacks

It's just over a year since King Kev resigned as manager of Newcastle United and issued the following statement:

"I've been working desperately hard to find a way forward with the directors but sadly that has not proved possible.  It's my opinion that a manager must have the right to manage and that clubs should not impose upon any manager any player that he does not want.  I have been left with no choice other than to leave."

Shortly after his resignation, Keegan lodged a claim for unfair .  Keegan is reportedly claiming £10 million in compensation and costs, and a long-awaited tribunal is due to sit next week.

Bullied Green Keeper Wins Compensation For Constructive Dismissal

| No TrackBacks

Andrew Beck, who suffers from Asperger's Syndrome and learning difficulties, has been awarded £78,000 in compensation for constructive dismissal and disability discrimination.

An employment tribunal ruled Mr. Beck's supervisor bullied and intimidated him for a number of years while he worked as a green keeper at Davyhulme Park Golf Club. 

He was told to wear a red hat to distinguish him from other staff and to alert golfers to his presence.  He was also ordered to carry heavy equipment in a wheelbarrow after he was banned from using a motorised vehicle, meaning that his duties involved an unfair amount of heavy work, often without breaks.

One Christmas, staff received presents -- Mr. Beck was given a Star Wars game, however, and felt humiliated because it was only suitable for children.  On another occasion, his supervisor approached him from behind and violently knocked a rake out of his hands.  He then pushed him out of the way, using bad language.

Mr. Beck eventually resigned due to poor health.