Block on Trump's Asylum Ban Upheld by Supreme Court
McAllister v. Price, 10-1213, concerned a challenge to the district court's denial of summary judgment to an officer claiming qualified immunity, in plaintiff's suit, claiming that the officer violated his Fourth Amendment rights by using excessive force to remove plaintiff from his car following a car crash.
In affirming, the court held that, given the extent of plaintiff's injuries and the evidence linking them to defendant's conduct, the district court did not err in concluding that plaintiff's injuries were relevant to determining whether defendant used excessive force. The district court did not err in finding a genuine issue of material fact regarding plaintiff's diabetic condition. The court held that evidence is sufficient for a jury to conclude that defendant's use of force was excessive. Lastly, the court held that defendant's conduct, slamming an unresponsive, convulsing driver into the ground with force sufficient to break the driver's hip and place his knee on the driver's back with enough force to bruise his lung, goes beyond the bounds of the plaintiff's clearly established Fourth Amendment rights and thus deprives the defendant of qualified immunity.