Block on Trump's Asylum Ban Upheld by Supreme Court
District court's issuance of the writ of habeas corpus for a defendant claiming that the key witness in his murder trial was the shooter who killed the victim is reversed where: 1) the only significant evidence in the record showing what an uncalled witness would have testified, if produced, is a letter that actually implicates defendant for the shooting, not the key witness who testified against him; 2) it is clear from the record that defendant was not prejudiced by his lawyer's failure to locate and call the uncalled witness; and 3) the prosecutor's statements did not constitute improper vouching because the key witness's charge was in the record and his personal interest in the case was obvious to the jury.
Argued: November 19, 2009
Decided and Filed: December 15, 2009
Opinion by Circuit Judge Merritt
For Appellant: Brian O'Neill, Office of the Michigan Attorney General
For Appellee: Joan Ellerbusch Morgan